Is Foreign Direct Investment FDI in retail in India sector good?
Last Updated: Mar 13, 2013
Is FDI in Retail in India good for country
FDI in retail in Inida
I strongly oppose FDI retail in India, because we already lost our country by leaving other countries to enter into our India, again we should not leave our mother country. Indians are having good skill. Indians are worth to set up Indian companies similar to Walmart. Even new technologies can be brought by us people also
FDI is just the mirror of falling Indian trading and administrative system. It is good in present scenario, but could proved ill in long term for the nation.
FDI in retail in Inida
For instance govt has invested 1000 crore of public fund inviting Walmart, what when Walmart fail all the govt investment goes to ashes, instead of govt I will suggest private branded firms would invest money if they are really looking it as a business, and I believe private firms could handle situations in better way as govt always fails.
I support FDI in infrastructure, services and less in retail.
India a huge consumer and thus very attractive place for trading of its loose foreign trading policy. Use nations for bringing technology and stable system with culture in India, but control should be in our hand.
For inviting the retail company like Walmart in India, Indian govt need to invest thousand of crores to let them in India, the govt will only use the public money for such investment. We hardly bother about our takes that we are paying to govt and how govt is misusing this,
For instance govt has invested 1000 crore of public fund inviting Walmart, what when Walmart fail all the govt investment goes to ashes, instead of govt I will suggest private branded firms would invest money if they are really looking it as a business, and I believe private firms could handle situations in better way as govt always fails.
Secondly FDI in retail in India is always preferred by the developed countries to increase their productivity not by developing countries, our politicians political bill is limited to get money only and nothing else, so FDI is not good for the time being, India again retain its credibility and stood on his foot, then FDI is good else its just solace to support.
Tell us Your Queries, Suggestions and Feedback
145 Responses to Is Foreign Direct Investment FDI in retail in India sector good?
« What is MBA In Material Management & which are the top colleges for it? Family owned business vs professionally run businesses »
I strongly oppose to FDI, because we already lost our country by leaving other countries to enter into our India, again we should not leave our mother country.if fdi came in our country then crime should be incresed. so i totally oppose FDI.
because if fdi came then local sailors become unemployed so the crime will increase.
fdi is harmful for our country so i totally oppose the fdi.
I think FDI in Retail Sector is good for India, it provides a big scope for jobs in retail sector.
it will provide best imported products at cheap rates. the products like cosmetics, electronic gadgets of top foreign M.N.Cs that we can’t buy today are easily available for us after FDI comes in India.
for me its a BOON for Retail sector. & if Politics concerns then i can say that. the work of Opposition parties who ever it is to oppose any step taken by current government. so in a nutshell i say that we all should welcome FDI in India it is very much good for us
Yes i think FDI in retail sector is good for india because it will provide us with more and better opportunities. FdI wil bring Modern technology to the country aand it will improve rural infrastructure which could also help to bring better infrastructure and create a competitive market. Also it will reduce wastage of crops and gives better prices of the crops.
Governement can also expect to get more profit through taxes by aloowing FDI in India. consumers can get commodites of daily uses at reduced prices.Biggest Benefit of FdI in retail sector is for small Farmers who can get profit and can improve there productivity by directly selling to large organizations.
For instance govt has invested 1000 crore of public fund inviting Walmart, what when Walmart fail all the govt investment goes to ashes, instead of govt I will suggest private branded firms would invest money if they are really looking it as a business, and I believe private firms could handle situations in better way as govt always fails.
FDI is a risk taking part for the Indian economy. As India is a developing country, for some time foreign investment robustly increases local productivity growth at a time and at a same time demoralize the local companies where government can invest to increase the local productivity and create more employment by itself.
foreign direct investment (fdi) is not good in retail sector for india. there is lots of indian people are in this business means to say in retail sector.and if fdi is coming in retail there are many peoples are jobless who is in retail sector.
and also they are take many things through foreign not by indian farmer so there are farmer also are jobless.
thats why fdi is not good in retail sector but in other secctor it is good.
india is a developing country but how long we are in this condition.at the last we have to move on to the developed country for that we have to invest in other country as well as do other country investing our nation also.
there no mediaters in the market so customer get their product on original price so there is no concept of price hikes
wallmart will going to come in the markets so there is lakhs of job opportunity for freshers
there is a symbiosis between the international and national government
FDI is good and also bad for us, if allow 51% fund to Foreign company then according to conpany law 143 section 2[a] the other part can take over the company so we should allow fund investment’s but less than 50% then is usse ful for us because indin people can also will get the job in company shops..
Secondly FDI is always preferred by the developed countries to increase their productivity not by developing countries, our politicians political bill is limited to get money only and nothing else, so FDI is not good for the time being, India again retain its credibility and
I strongly oppose to FDI.because It can be the way for foreigners to enter India.If we allow FDI in retail sector then our small level industries shops will be ended. this will cause the unemployment.this can be one wrong step for our economy growth.
when these companies came into market they will earlier provide products at lower prices comparison to
small level shops so small level shops will not able to compete. after that they are single in market. they will sell their products at high prices and peoples have to boy.
If we see history of these foreign retail company like wallmart in other developed countries, wallmart had not been accepted by peoples .and these retail company had backed out. then how can be say that these company will give economy growth to India.
If we talk about about medium and lower class peoples they borrow their products from shops.and pay the money when they got salary.but if wallmart came into market these companies will not allow borrowing so these companies will not succeed.
i am not supported FDI in india because it has change our traditoin ,mainly it affected retailer (belonging to middle class family) ,increasing unemployement,which already a big assets .
as we always say “as you sow,as you reap”.so,instead of involving FDI ,need to concern about our indians people, by providing such investments ,stragedy. that’s better for economic growth or for peoples.
i don’t think ,it gives new trends to india ,even it may be results of other crisis in future.
As per as i concern it is good for india because due to this we can get many advantages like –
> foreign money will come in india : which will be beneficial for our country to go in a better way.
>employment will increase .
>it will be beneficial for the farmers : As we know we have broker system in india due to this farmer are not able to get that much profit which they can get by direct sell .
>If wallmart type company will come then it will also provide us many facilities like :-
* cold storage ( which we have less due to that farmers are getting loss because of wastage of food material)
* good infrastructure will also come
so at the fag end i would say that everyyhing has advantage n disadvantage but we mostly choose that which is more beneficial so it is in india.
Well the economy of India is very much self sustained , but with increasing population and demand of foreign services in the Indian market have com plead the government to take the step of introducing Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) in Indian market.
The economic downfall in the world economy is another factor for this decision of the government. To make the Indian economy much stronger the foreign currency must be allowed to get invested in India. Even the Indian market NSE and BSE has also welcomed this decision with an increase of 300 & 150 points respectively with its approval.It wont create unemployment but will increase the productivity and Quality of the goods.
But yes, the government must regulate the interest of the Small scale investors so that the big multi-retail giants cannot demoralizer them.
FDI will affect the economy in good and bad ways.First of all it will be tough for small business which are native to be alive or exist.Cause FDI will going to overtake the local Indian business.
But FDI going to offer more opportunity and for job and new business as well.New ideas for business will help local business.Overall my notion about FDI in retail sector is good for India .
Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) is good as well as bad for India .As ,if we concern about the quality and availability of products it is good . But if we concern about small scale businesses and retail shops ,it should not be a good news for them because they will lag somewhere because of foreign investment in Indian market.
It will provide employment also, and also because of this Indian market will definitely get down. So, as far as i am concerned, it is good as well as bad for retail sector………
yes of course it is good for India. FDI allows more and more opportunities in India and it gives more better product.
of indian people in the country.The infrastructure is good and large amount of money is invested !!!!
FDI, you are most welcome..
foreign direct investment will surely be contributing to the country’s growth..
more employment
more options to pick up in retail.
more facilities under one roof .
more infrastructure development.
cheaper goods.
eventually it will conclude to India’s success over world globe.
FDI is risk taking part for the indian economy.As india is a developing country,for some time foreign investement robustly increases local productivity growth at a time and at a same time demoralize the local companies where government can invest to increase local productivity and create more employment by itself.
according to my understanding if FDI comes in the current action it will divide the country into various sectors:- such as retailers,farmers thus repeating the history of ” divide n rule” with a twist
.yes their is no doubt about that it will help up bring the infrastructure but their is another side Of story
as for me the Government should have an upper hand on the country and not the foreign market
.
I does not support FDI , since it ultimately leads to the falling of indian government.Indians are having good skill and are intelligent enough to set up their own companies . giving chance to foreign companies will ultimately leads to fall down of our resources . Even new technologies can be brought by us people also. The other reason for which it is criticized is FDI is always preferred by the developed countries to increase their productivity not by developing countries.
Yes, obviously it is good because it helps to our economy and provide better aportinuities to coustemers to by any think which can be a pin or it can be a car or etc. so we have no. of choise any we get good quality goods in cheaper prices . Any it can not be harm any shopkepper in any way because if they provide good goods in same price in comparsion to mool than they cann’t failed.
i strongly support FDI. there are following reason for it first of all it promote the foreign currency into our country. which give much strengths both in liquidity and support our economy. FDI is more important as compared to other policy in term of the creation of job. this policy not only give strength to the currency but also create lacks of job which enhance the life cycle of the people thus in my opinion FDI is good for our economy.
fdi is quite beneficial for india as it it would enhance the infranstructure of india. indian government has allowed fdi in india with an agreement to invest half of its money in the infrastructure … thus FDI would would improve the storage capacity and transportation facilities and thus more goods would be used. fdi would decrease the wastage of goods and thus will be proved very baneficial in india. as india lacked because of their inavailability in storage n transportation.
fdi is good for our country because as we know that our country is not good in storage system so they have better storage system as comparison to our country.
fdi retailers direct contact to our farmers but in our country procedure there are lots of retailers involve when the farmer sell their raw material to the retailers because of this reason farmers not got much amount for their product and also when the material comes to the consumer they pay much amount but if fdi comes then the amount of the product will be less so fdi is good for our country.
according to me there should be fdi in retail sector because by doing this our country will get more exposre and employment and this will make our country financially strong.in present senareo the financial condition of our country is not so gud.so that FDI IN RETAIL IS VERY IMPORTANT FOR THE DEVELOPEMENT OF OUR COUNTRY……………
According to me FDI is not a correct option for our country for development, since we all know from our ancestors that they have suffered a lot due to british peaple came in india to trade with our old kings and somehow use there divide and rule policy to decrease our nations strength.The FDI is also something like this which will also affect our country in the same way in long term.
so i will conclude with my opinion that GOVT. should not allow wallmart or something like this to come and business in india, instead they should start some means for earning money to the common people.