Reservation in Promotions

Dec 15 • Group Discussion, Opinion • 6922 Views • 96 Comments on Reservation in Promotions

Reservation in Promotions

Although reservation in promotion is a matter of group discussion but as India is a free country and I am free to say or speak what so ever i like so i will start to advocate reservation for post of Prime minister , after all most of the time they have been earlier cabinet ministers and then latter in other elections they have been promoted to PM position

Reservation in Promotions

Reservation in Promotions

Reservation for SC/ST

Reservation for Minorities

Reservation for Woman

Reservation for refugees

Reservation for physically Handicapped and now Reservation in Promotions

(Bus karo yar Bache ki jan loge kya)

There is proposal to provide reservation to SC and STs in government job promotions at the rate of 15% and 7.5% respectively.This is ridiculous and dangerous step.It will result in conflict in the society and promote inequality ,due to this seniors will became juniors.They are waiting for 30-40 years to get the promotion but due to this there is an injustice between them , the people who are having reservation can get the promotion erlier than the seniors ,this will create an inequality between them. Majority of the benefits that are supposed to go to entire SC/ST community are garned by very few rich and influencial ones. The same gang gets theire priority in everything right from admission to schools ,colleges ,post graduations ,appointments and now ready to in promotions also.

Generally the Indian constitution makers proposed the reservation for 10 years only , but still its going on in favour of SC/ST only , all the politicians are very much concerned about the SC/ST only  but why not GEN/OBC .The OBC personnel are not getting any benefits at par with SC/ST .If this will be continued in the future definitely there will be a chance that OBC willbe becoming dalit.

Reservation is painful for people . I would like the reservation be there based on the economic conditions and those who are poor irrespective of  caste or religion  should be given opportunities . The government should eliminate  all  caste system and only one caste remains and that is INDIAN.

Please feel free to write your views in the comment section

Tell us Your Queries, Suggestions and Feedback

Your email address will not be published.

96 Responses to Reservation in Promotions

  1. Rishav gupta says:

    GD topics in simple language

  2. Nandita Pradhan says:

    Reservation for the SC/ST must be stopped. Reservation takes away the chances of the common people who really deserved that. If we take reservation of seats to be ok but threrafter we cannot take reservation of seats for promotion to be ok.
    Promotion should be made according to the capability and qualification and ability not as per the reserved . Reservation may be for certain years but many political party carries on with that in order to increase their vote banks. Reservation against economic condition can be accepted to some extent. Poor peoples due to insufficient money are not able do certain things like courses, purchase job appearing forms . In such cases reservation can be accepted but in all it cant be accepted. Because people should get promotion and other chances in order of their capability not in basis of just reservation.

  3. Keshav Bhagat says:

    According to my opinion Reservation should be applicable only for those individual people who are lagging with their financial background and failed to managed for fill a examination fee. Every country have it’s GDP rate and GDP rate of any country depends on the status and capabilities of the citizens. If we are promoting them on the basis of caste (Reservations) & they don’t have such ability to lead them at the peak. So this is unfair for the deserving candidate as well as for our country….

    So the entire reservation system need a change and should be done on the economic condition o the people and not on the basis of caste and in promotions it will be done on the basis of the performance of an individual so that he or she will be motivated to perform more better for the growth of the organisation and thus for the country.

    so my conclusion is the reservation name complitly remove from indian constitution for same respect and providing jobs to person who is capable for that job……

  4. Rajib Dey says:

    Reservation is a necessary devil of our country. On one hand, it has played a vital role in uprising of lower casts of India, On the other hand the development of our country as a whole has suffered greatly.In the govt. jobs promotion gets after a very lony time service and perfomance and after that if we judge any one by their cast and not give them promotion in unfair . According to me reservation only for those who are lagging with their financial problem and also good in work and serives .Most of the high post in government sector are occupied by backward class people and giving them promotion on the basis of reservation to them is like icing on cake. Promotions should be made totally on the basis of their performance not on there caste.

  5. Kinsuk Sadhukhan says:

    According to me the reservation should be applicable only for those individuals who are lagging with their financial background as they failed to managed even to fill a examination fee. GDP rate of any country depends on the status and capabilities of the citizens, if we are promoting them on the basis of caste & they don’t have such ability to lead them at the peak. reservation in promotion not good, because in our constitution reservation is provide that people that belongs to bellow poverty line.Reservation is not the point to take into account when delivering a greater responsibilitity to a man. Promotions should given according to their performance. A man/woman who is serving the people in a better way then other should be eligible for promotion.

  6. Siddhant Tripathi says:

    First of all writing about the policy.. it’s a real hideous mock of the talented and skillful class of society.
    I just don’t understand that if people have the talent to rise to success heights, if the people have the potential to be at the top, if the people have the skills to prove their “metal” in the competitive era then why the hell do we require theses reservation anywhere.. leave alone the case of promotions in jobs ‘n posts?
    It’s so simple for the “big heads” sitting above us with “no heads at all” to confide with the fact that even the reserved category students have skills and talents.. far better than the comparative general class.
    All they require is “opportunity” and not “reservation.”
    Reservation based promotion is going to create sort of job dissatisfaction in the working class of the society. People will oppose.. definitely oppose the idea of any reserved category candidate being promoted before him/her just because he/she belonged to a reserved category, irrespective of the tenure of the work they had been involved in the company, the experience of the individual, the contribution of that person in the company’s turnover, etc.
    This is “injustice” in my opinion and never again such filthy policy should be considered for implementation.

  7. Saurabh Jajoo says:

    reservation was a step taken by the government to give the enough opportunities to the backward people.
    but now it becomes a very major point of distraction. reservation in promotion is the rediculus feet taken by the government. Actually reservation for selection is ok but in promotion the thing to be tested is experience and workability not the cast. by giving reservation you have given a chance to rise them but reservation in promotion means we are making them lazy , and also the good working and experienced person of general cast will not work properly because they knows whatever they do they will not be permoted. so reservation in promotion should be removed.

  8. Vikas Chaubey says:

    Reservation in promotions is a dangerous step. It will result in conflict in the society and promote inequality. Seniors will became juniors. That’s why SP is opposing the bill, which is also against the basic tenets of the Constitution,” said Mulayam, after meeting a delegation of the Moallim-e-Urdu degree holders.

    However, according to press release issued by the SP, Mulayam justified Muslim quota. “Reports of the Sachar committee, the Rangnath Commission found, that the socio-economic status of Muslims is worse than Dalits, hence the minority community needs the benefit of reservation, which will bring them at par with other classes in the society.

    Mulayam said that the Congress led UPA government formed the Sachar Committee and Rangnath Commission to study the status of minorities in the country and suggest ways to improve it. However, he added, the major recommendations of the two committees, which included quota in government jobs and educational institutions, have not been implemented. He said that he will continue to mount pressure on the Centre to bring legislation for providing minority quota.

    The SP leader also recalled how he along with other leaders struggled for years for implementation of reservation for the other backward classes in government jobs and educational institutions.

    Assuring Muslims that ‘one day they will get benefit of reservation’, Mulayam, who recently bailed out the Congress led UPA government at the centre on the issue of foreign direct investment( FDI) in multi-brand retail in the Parliament, said that the Congress and Bhartiya Janta Party(BJP) are working together against formation of a non-Congress-BJP Third Front.

    He said that the two parties want Indian politics to revolve around them with no space for a third front. However, Mulayam, who has prime-ministerial ambition, also said that he strongly feels that both the parties will lose in 2014 Lok Sabha elections, paving way for the formation of the Third Front.

    Political analysts say that Mulayam is opposing quota in promotion because it affects backward classes and Muslims, apart from upper castes. The SP’s vote bank mainly comprises backward classes and Muslims. However, a small percentage of Dalits have also been supporting the SP.

    By opposing reservation in promotions, the Yadav Satrap has taken the risk of losing Dalit votes. However, he seems to be confident about compensating the loss with votes from upper castes, which are impressed by his open opposition to reservation in promotions. At the same time, he wants to keep Muslims in good humour by promising them quota benefit.

  9. Divya Acharya says:

    IM IN AGAINST OF RESERVATION IN PROMOTION ,
    according to me there must be no reservation in promotion,because it must be given according to the ability and knowledge and progress rate of the person who is working in the association.
    by giving reservation may be some deserving person wont get the apportunity to excel.

  10. Jagriti Singh says:

    According to me the there should not be any type of reservation for any caste or religion.. Reservation should be totally banned or if it is then it should be totally depends on the economical conditions nor on the basis of caste. If the person has a talent then he/she deserves the seats which are reserved due to reservation and due to this they have to suffer.

  11. BHARAT GAUTAM says:

    There is proposal to provide reservation to SC and STs in government job promotions.This reservation follows the general person throughout his life.

    But this reservation system should be eliminated. And give the opportunity to the person who is desirable for the chance.

    There are so many problems that are generated by the reservation i.e. corruption. By removing reservation we could get so many solutions for so many problems in india.

  12. Abhimanyu Gupta says:

    I am completely against the Reservation in Promotions.Initially in INDIA Reservation is Proposed for 10 years so that people of backward classes can get a initial help and this time is also sufficient for them to develop themselves BUT today EVEN AFTER 65 YEARS OF INDEPENDENCE Reservation is there and also increasing. Initially Reservation is there in Education, in JOBS but now it is also proposed in PROMOTIONS also.I think it’s not good for a country and the complete Reservation system has to be changed and Reservation should be given on the basis of ECONOMIC condition of a person.In jobs Promotion should be on the basis of quality of a person, his performance so that everyone will be motivated to give their 100% to their work which directly increases the GROWTH of Organisation and also good for country.

  13. Nitin Kalani says:

    i am against the reservation in promotions.in india reservation is based on cast.basically indian constitute allow reservation for 10 years but many politics parties carry this process for their vote banks. if there is reservation then high cast people who is more intelligent then the reserve cast people is miss their opportunity and it is not good for our nation .besides this , less knowledgeable person are in high position and they make decision which slow down our country growth.

  14. Swarnima Gupta says:

    AGAINST:
    The concept of reservation was initially introduced in Indian constitution to remove the problem of inequality from it’s root which at that time mainly existed as problem for ST/SC’s because of pre independence scenario. It was suggested to be implemented only for initial 20 years but it was keep on extending continues till now, if we really have respect for ideas of constitution makers & believe in our constitution then we should have also respected this idea of theirs.If this Reservation promotion continues in this way no later there would be a time when each caste & tribe of India will demand for it & the main aim of constitution makers to remove INEQUALITY from nation would persist to exist with no final solution.
    We do realize that sometimes there do exist a need for providing some extra benefits to some people,but at that time the intellectual act would be decide on questions like what kind of benefits could be provided without doing injustice to others & for how much time it should be given.Like it is right to give educational benefits to economically backward people but this should be done in fields that candidates should be provide with free books but at the same time entrance criteria in any institutions should be truly done on merit basis.There could be many other ways to implement this scheme for which ways should be searched out by government.

  15. Gaurav Garg says:

    I think reservation should based on economic condition of human life. We should give priority to those who are deserving candidates although students who are from poor background but they have talent irrespective
    to their cast. But in promotion their should be no reservation because of this junior member becomes senior members along with he have not proper knowledge so this is harmful for social and senior person (deserving person) have to wait so many years for promotions . Thus i think that their should be no reservation in promotion.

  16. Abhishek Gupta says:

    I am against the reservation in promotions. In INDIA reservation is based on the caste from more than 60 years which is initially proposed for only 10 years. from starting at very low level that is from school to higher education and then for jobs their is reservation on the basis of caste which is not justified totally now if we also provide the reservation in promotions then they may not justified their work or do their work with the same dedication. So the entire reservation system need a change and should be done on the economic condition o the people and not on the basis of caste and in promotions it will be done on the basis of the performance of an individual so that he or she will be motivated to perform more better for the growth of the organisation and thus for the country.

  17. satveer singh says:

    This increases the differences between castes. And decreases the working power of lower castes.
    A general cast man firstly struggle for job and then in job also he has to struggle for promotion.
    And we are dipressing the talent by promoting this reservation.

  18. rohit kumar bhutiya says:

    According to me yes reservation should be there but yes it should be based on seeing the economic conditions of the poor who are suffering a lot for their survival and the poor irrespective of caste or religion should be given opportunities…

  19. ANSHUL SINHA says:

    Obviously, I am against for reservation for promotions , as does everyone. The talent, honesty and hard work towards the job are the only criteria that must be considered while promoting the individual. Promoting a person just because of a surname does not seem to be just enough. It creates a complete chaos moreover block the way to the appropriate candidate.

  20. Mridul Jain says:

    * the motive for the reservation according to cast was to raise the level of cast and particularly the economical condition of the cast…but this decision of govt. is irrelevant to that is will just create the racism and it will apart the society only.
    * some day we will be knowing the India on the base of cast only.
    * this is tearing apart the India and not letting the real talent come forward.
    * reservation in job giving might be right till a level but then in promotion and increment too….. its pathetic ..

  21. Shelly Jain says:

    According to my opinion Reservation should be applicable only for those individual people who are lagging with their financial background and failed to managed for fill a examination fee. Every country have it’s GDP rate and GDP rate of any country depends on the status and capabilities of the citizens. If we are promoting them on the basis of caste (Reservations) & they don’t have such ability to lead them at the peak. So this is unfair for the deserving candidate as well as for our country. Many people have capability for their promotions but due to reservation undeserved people fill their seat. People of general cast hurt many times due to reservation. So i would like to conclude that reservation simply creates differences amongst the community.

  22. Shelly Jain says:

    According to my opinion Reservation should be applicable only for those individual people who are lagging with their financial background and failed to managed for fill a examination fee. Every country have it’s GDP rate and GDP rate of any country depends on the status and capabilities of the citizens. If we are promoting them on the basis of caste (Reservations) & they don’t have such ability to lead them at the peak. So this is unfair for the deserving candidate as well as for our country. Many people have capability for their promotions but due to reservation undeserved people fill their seat. People of general cast hurt many times due to reservation. So i would like to conclude that reservation simply creates differences amongst the community.

  23. durgashankar saini says:

    the reservation are not good for in education and government job .because the senior will became junior due to the reservation .the SC and ST wiil have more reservation then OBC and general category.if we have 100 government job then the 17% reserve for ST and 12% for SC and remaining for other category.if those seats are vacant in SC and ST manner then we will not fill those sits through the other caste. so we analyze that the brilliant student who wiil not belong to sc and st they also not applicable due to the reservation.

  24. Gaurav Garg says:

    Its my bad luck that i born in a country like india where there is a very serious disease of RESERVATION is there.Reservation basically was made to help the poor and backward class people but at present time its a evil for all general class people.
    THE SON OF A S.T./S.C./O.B.C class father who is a good govr. doctor must not get reservation.
    And reservation in promotions are strictly not accpetable because it clearly cut out the all progress chance of general people….!!

  25. VISHAL JAIN says:

    Reservation is the big problem in India it was mainly came into for those people who are poor who can not higher education and those who were considered lower cast and not allow to come with higher class people.
    But today it is being taken in wrong way and only some well people, they are getting or we can say taking benefit of it, and those people who are indeed are not getting benefit of it. This system is giving problem to those student who are trying very hard but cannot get through cause of reservation till now but now in reservation in promotions will cause same problem in the Govt. offices.

  26. MOHIT JAIN says:

    Reservations in promotions, in my opinion is a total crap and such rules should not be imparted in the parliament. First of all there is a law for the reservation for the SC/ST’s and other backward classes which provide them a wide range of relaxations in government as well as some of the private scenarios.They enjoy upto a great extent by getting a large quota for themselves.I,being from a jainism background can even too demand my reservation rights because our community is also one of the few communities with very less people.The point we don’t demand reservation the government would not look upto us?
    In my opinion the evil of reservation has gripped society in its firm grip that would deteroriate nation’s talent and thirst to evolve as an individual and finally reservations and that too in Promotions is totally unfair and unproductive.

  27. MANU SHARMA says:

    Reservation is a necessary devil of our country. On one hand, it has played a vital role in uprising of lower casts of India, On the other hand the development of our country as a whole has suffered greatly. The fact that reservation was given in order for uprising of lower casts the but the outcome is not that effective as our politicians expected.
    Our politician are now bringing a new bill which says that there should be a reservation in promotion. I strongly feel that this bill should be brought into work but effectively. The work of every citizen should be thoroughly considered before promoting him. As the promotion is a very important aspect of our life, there should not be any case where a person was just discarded because he belongs to the upper cast.
    So I would like to conclude by saying that there should be scrutiny before promoting a person and though the bill should be implemented, it should concentrate only upon the uprising of India.

  28. sagar saxena says:

    How such ridiculous proposols can even come in the minds of the people sitting there at the parliament. On one hand we use to talk about equality and on other we are just planning for reservations???
    We have already pressurised the general category people a lot by providing reservations in education , government jobs and almost everywhere. But now in Promotions???
    its just like one has committed a fault to born in a general category family. If we actually want to set up equality we surely have to drop this idea of reservation from all the places…
    atleast from the promotions so that a person can be satisfied with the fact that if he gets a job he can surely get promotions on the basis of his capabilities.

  29. samiksha yadav says:

    As per as my view reservation is not good in govt. jobs , we can’t judge any ones ability according to their cast and category.
    In the govt. jobs promotion gets after a very lony time service and perfomance and after that if we judge any one by their cast and not give them promotion in unfair . according to me reservation only for those who are lagging with their financial problem and also good in work and serives .
    in our country this unfair system is prefered ,but the gdp rate of any country depends on the status and capabilities of the citizens, if we are promoting them on the basis of caste & they don’t have such ability to lead them at the peak. so , dont make any criterion in the govt or any jobs for promotion according to the cast.

  30. maharshi vyas says:

    In my point of view,reservation should be only to those who are weak economically. Not everyone should get in accordance to caste system,it will hide the effectiveness and intelligency of any candidate. Practically i have seen in my district a negetive marked candidate selected in RPSC,now tell me wat he will teach.. Guyyys please say no to this type of reservation and move towards it. It should be based on the economical conditions only.

  31. Shaheen Khan says:

    I like to say that this “Reservation” word is a tight slap on the face of India. It is a very foolish idea to give promotion on reservation basis. There is a clear logic that if you have a talent then you will get promotion. Just only for collecting the votes of public, government puts these types of bill in parliament and try to pass it. It never think for the welfare for people. I want to ask from the govt. that what are the scheme declared by the govt. for poor people as they are belong to OBC & General. I think reservation should be on the basis of financial condition. In this way reservation is really helpful otherwise it is worthless.

  32. Ravindra Singh says:

    Reservation is the very popular topic in parliament that raised oftentimes used at the time of elections by the ministers .”WHY RESERVATION”this should be very famous title on that a super-hit movie can make ,
    At the old time the reservation is for only that deserves it “EVERYBODY KNOW THE NAME OF ‘BHEAM RAV AMBEDEKER NOBODY KNOW THE NEME OF THE PERSON THAT MAKE HIM ABLE TO BE COULD ALL THAT AND PROVIDE SCHOLARSHIP THAT WAS THE KING OF KHETRINAGAR(now in jhujhunu) MAHARAJA AJIT SINGH “. that was all done in old time also and after independence of India it being a law and it is just for whom that not able to expose them to give a platform to enhancement of them but in promotion there is a quality should matter if it is than surely he was given the chance to improvement but this is like the exploitation of others it not to be happen .
    atlast shortly i want to say that it will not fair with other if they provide reservation in promotion.,

  33. Narendra Chouhan says:

    in my opinion reservation in promotion should given to only those persons who don’t have enough resources to live and feed themselves.this reservation in promotion is becoming a cause of protest among the citizens..as i think if reservation in these fields remains continued it will directely affect the nation because it develop barriers for the economic growth of nation in indirect manner.it should not be based upon cast basis.

  34. PALLAVI DUBEY says:

    It will lead to danger consequences ..
    It will support inequality and may lead to conflict…
    The Promotion should be given on the basis of quality of work , experience and most importantly the self behaviour towards the organisation …
    We have to stop it , we dont want castism everywhere …
    We want some strict moves guys …ask yourself “Are we serious and honest about ourselves ?”….

  35. RICHA SHARMA says:

    A big NO..to reservation.and that too in the promotions.Nah.
    If a person steps up a ladder,let him climb by himself,and not on the basis of his surname.
    Reservation in professional exams ,is anyway a big debate but in promotions,its a straight NO.
    Believe in yourself..your own talents and abilities and not on the caste or religion u belong to.
    One is defined by his name and known by his actions,and succeeds by his talents and behaviour.
    Here,in this stream..the surname does’nt fit any cord.Its not only unfair to the ones who are more worthy of the promotion(from unreserved cateogary)but also to the institution,it wont help anywhere to its growth.
    So if ur thinking for reservation in promotions,then do give it second thoughts with honesty.Answer will be clearer then!

  36. PALLAVI DUBEY says:

    Reservation In Promotion will lead to danger consequences ..
    It will support inequality and may lead to conflict…
    The Promotion should be given on the basis of quality of work , experience and most importantly the self behaviour towards the organisation …
    We have to stop it , we dont want castism everywhere …
    We want some strict moves guys …ask yourself “Are we serious and honest about ourselves ?”….

  37. khushboo soni says:

    No i am not agree with it ,, there should not at all reservations in promotions !! Because a well known saying ” A mistake is not called mistake if its done repetadely then its called the stupidity ” , same saying applies on here because we had already given reservation in the education system a lot which lead a negative impact in the case of talent and giving them again promotion is like elimination of talented people from the society and hence an uneducated system so the uneducated country. Because due to reservation many of the talented people cann’t be able to move on as reserved peoples find the platform not because of their talent but beacuse of their reservation ,,and again providing them same criteria in cases of promotion will be the insane work and it will lead only and only an uneducated system & and uneducated peoples are the part of poverty , crimes , terrorism etc. & thus resist the growth of company!

  38. Herry Singh says:

    THERE SHOULD BE NO MORE RESERVATION

    * WE ALREADY HAVE 54 % RESERVATION IN RAJASTHAN STATE ONLY WHAT WILL HAPPEN TO THE GENERAL CATEGORY.

    * IF THERE ARE MORE RESERVATIONS THE GENERAL CATEGORY WILL BECOME A MINORITY.

    * BOTH POLITICAL PARTIES SP AND BSP FIGHT FOR JUSTICE OF DALITS BUT ONLY BSP DEMANDS RESERVATION IN PROMOTION AND SP DOESNT CAN ANYONE EXPLAIN THIS????

  39. vishnu jangid says:

    reservation in promotion is so bed that we should stop it reservation in promotion is benefit only st and sc and they get benefit and promotion should done your qualification and your work experience according to me today also stop reservation in necesarory and need divide cast there actual income and there field income and reservation in our country should be vain and today politicion is done politicine ony reservation which is not good for our country we should think our country and our economy system ok stoppppppppppppppp this it is like evil our country

  40. Tarun Mahayech says:

    OMG..!! Everybody is opposing reservation. Just because they can’t see any SC or ST candidate at higher posts. Reservation is not the cause for inequality, infact this is just a right provided to them so that the other people claiming to belong from upper castes could have a equality with them.

  41. Ronak Garg says:

    Initially reservation aims to uplift the SC/ST, OBC and other backward classes of society who have not enough resources to live a decent life. But now this scenario has totally changed and general caste people are suffering. Most of the high post in government sector are occupied by backward class people and giving them promotion on the basis of reservation to them is like icing on cake. Promotions should be made totally on the basis of their performance not on there caste. Can any one tell why there is need of reservation in promotion? There is already reservation in selection process and hence there is no need for extra. So, I strongly oppose this proposal and it should be discarded without even thinking.

    Giving reservation is quite injustice to other people in society. Is it their fault not to be SC/ST. It is totally a violation of human rights i.e “Right to equal opportunities”.

  42. GAURAV SHARMA says:

    Reservation is one of the most sort after terms in our country. India as a whole is divided in two sections one comprising of those who support it and another of those who are against it. Reservation in promotion is one of the worst cases. Performance should be the barometer for promotion rather than reservation on any other basis. This criteria will not only motivate the individual to work hard but will also create healthy competitive environment. Reservation should only be limited to those people who are economically weak and does not have enough to support themselves. Government should carry out country wide surveys to identify this section of society and take measures accordingly rather than offering reservation to those who lead a luxurious life. Its like stealing bread and butter from needy thereby further crippling them. Moreover it also affect and depresses those who work hard to earn themselves what the deserve

  43. Shailender Singh says:

    There shouldn’t be any reservation in to the promotion of any sector,
    because the promotion is dependent on the ability of the person, if the person have ability to grow up for the post then the person should fight the competition for the post and then promote itself,
    reservation in the promotion process is not a good idea ,it is better to believe in yourself, your abilities, your talents and not on the cast you belong to, think it yourself

  44. JYOTI JAIN says:

    According to me reservation should be band in india. as we know that from reservation is only for ST/SC . we always hear that we all are equal. but by reservation we are are not equal. specially it happens with the general cast persons.in any compitetion exams and every place ST/SC candidates gets selected. general candidates those who are doing alot of strugles they gets always failur because of reservation .it is not sure that all ST/SC are poor. we know that general cast persons are also poor but they get nothing. according to me if better to remove all reservation completly . beside this if we give reservation for poors of all casts , then everyone has equal rights and its good for our india

  45. Shishupal Nagar says:

    reservation is not good for our country overall development and it will make diffrences in sociaty.

  46. DEVENDRA KUMAR GOYAL says:

    For promotions Reservation is not good because Reservation is only for those people who has under poverty line. But in promotion mean whose good in money or up to poverty line .So shoud not Reservation in Promotions.shoud be promoted whose has good knowledge.

  47. Shishupal Nagar says:

    Yes,It is happening now a days.But it is not for good salary it is for get good job. and do a impressive business himself.

  48. Lucky Joshi says:

    in my point of view , reservation be based on the economic condition of human life. and this is not to allowed for sc/st because every person in sc/st is not to poor condition so this based on economic condition..!!

  49. Mayank Sharma says:

    RESERVATION
    Which was started by the government to bring the minority people to come forward and to support them to fight with the world…
    Bt nowadays those people treats it as their right,i dont the reservation is their right.
    That was just a step for bringing them forward…
    as d world is growing we can even see the reservation while PROMOTIONS being given to the people,just because they are from ST,SC,OBC they are being promoted irrespective to the ability and capability..
    They are being equally atandard with the persons who have came through the life’s hurdles and the primary, hard work,patience and their ability.
    This was initiated because the General caste people use to promote only the generals… because of such people this originated. and till now it has so much engraved in the system that it is quite hard to deploy it.
    Hence if reservations for the promotion is there,the certain people should be thouroughly screened to grab that specific position,theyshould be examined deeply …
    nd the most deserving minority people shold be employed..
    This wont get rid of the Reservation setup but this would atleast assign the person who has passed through the Screening processs.

  50. ROHIT JANGID says:

    there are a bad policy of indian govt. to provide a reservation with basis of cast ..ya it is one side true that poor people have job and earn money…
    but thats policy is bad ..because in that level a talented peoples are not able to get promotions..and in any case which is related with this are remove from indian govt. policy…
    ya i know i am also a OBC cast people ,but i am agree with those people who are think that this policy is remove from indian GOVT.

  51. archana saini says:

    As per my views there should be no reservation in promotions. reservation should be based on the economic condition of the employ and promotions should be based on the seniority,knowledge of the person.Due to reservation based promotions the love and respect for each other almost finishes and they start to criticize each other which is not good for govt. and as well for society.the employ which has no reservation also get frustrated and does not do his work honestly.

  52. Satyavan Fauzdar says:

    yes sir you r right,it is rediculus that in our country reservation is given on cast system,b’coz our constitution says that there is similarity in every cast than how can reservasion based on cast,it should be based on economic standard of people.then every men can say that he is living a very good life in our nation.

  53. Himanshu Verma says:

    I personally think that reservation criteria is such a bad thing in all the fields because due to reservation those people selected sometime who does not deserve that thing. In promotions only those people get the promotion who have eligibility to get that promotion. The person is fulfill all the criteria of promotion activity only those will be selected for the promotions. so i think promotion reservation activity in any field is not good and i request from the government please remove all these rules of reservation and provide equality to everyone.

  54. Pravin Singh Shekhawat says:

    according to my views the system of reservation through indian governance rule completely destroy because it also create a violence between human beings because actually reservation which is made for those people who cant get profit thrugh this
    proposal to provide reservation to SC and STs in government job promotions at the rate of 15% and 7.5% respectively.This is ridiculous and dangerous step.It will result in conflict in the society and promote inequality ,due to this seniors will became juniors.They are waiting for 30-40 years to get the promotion but due to this there is an injustice between them , the people who are having reservation can get the promotion erlier than the seniors ,this will create an inequality between them. Majority of the benefits that are supposed to go to entire SC/ST community are garned by very few rich and influencial ones.

  55. ritambhara pandey says:

    I will not support Reservation in promotion because reservation in education has already given to those people who need this…and by this who really deserve that reservation, got jobs……but reservation also in promotion!!if someone really good with his work,so he don’t need any reservation in promotion…promotion only can get by dignity and hard work…not by reservation….

  56. ankit dhingra says:

    WHY W-H-Y is this reservation word getting into the nerves of government for these sc\st people ,It’s nothing but just another step by government towards promotion of inequalities among the people of the country . Does this reservation fulfill the future demands of reservation by this hungry lot of sc\st people NO it will not …it just another piece of prepared food served to this poor India just to show that yes their is a lot more coming your way u can fetch anything .
    what kind of work these idiots will do after promotions the system will get more worst nothing else ..
    Earlier the clerk which was coming to office 2hour or sow past his duty time is getting promoted and is now eligible to come in lunch time or cane operate from home too..
    huh reservation in promotion .

  57. Vishakha Bansal says:

    Earlier reservation was given for only two years for development of some very backward cast’s people, but later this is become a point of getting votes for politicians and they increase it for their own sake. According to my point of view the reservation in promotions is not at all appreciable because due to this an deserving person don’t get right post but other person of xyz cast get promotion in spite of fact that his social and economical condition might be good from a general category person. So if we really want to give reservation then it should be given in field of education and on the basis of one’s economical conditions, not on the basis of cast so that a deserving person can attain a position of his choice.

  58. navin kumar says:

    according to my point reservation is painful for the people for ex. a person getting 10 marks in gate and select in IIT and another person get 30 marks then there is not selected in IIT because first person belongs to SC/ST and getting profit of reservation and another person ics not in SC/ST so this is not selected. so reservation is compltely remove our country .because reservation is allows for lower economy condition of these people.

  59. komal sharma says:

    reservations in promotions is not good for any other.because by providing reservations it is only applicable for below poverty lines and by providing reservations,they can get service with minimum marks and their lower capability.and if it will be done then who have intelligent and able person according to their quality in general…they will be not able to get their services and those who are in lower poverty line…they will easily provide their services in any field and it is not a good judgement for general category people..

  60. Vikas Lalwani says:

    Promotion of reservation is good for us, as people of SC/ST are giving more importance than GEN.In country like India we must treat all the peoples equally whether they belong to SC/ST or OBC or GEN,we must help the needy, those who are not able to earn should be given free education and opportunities. It is not good to divide people by caste because as there are many corrupt people who form SC/ST certificate whether they belong to SC/ST or from general they do this with the help of currption and take place of original Scheduled caste people in many competition. So,criteria of helping poor must be based on there current income value of family, not from their caste.

  61. Puja Agarwal says:

    Reservation in promotion should be abolished completely… as its a nonsense that reservation in promotion….people are waiting long for promotion but this sc/st people get a quick chance of promotion and the people who wre waiting long for propmotion dont even get a chance to promote…this people possess more knowledge the sc/st people who get a quick promotion and government has made a very wrong rule for sc/st peopleas this people are getting oppurtunity in every field from education to job…why is this happening do they have more brain then general people or they are not human being where is the point to promote sc/st people quickly……sc/st people should be oppurtunity rather then promoting them quickly….now sc/st people are no more poor they all reached the level of general people …even more then a general people this is only because that government provide them more oppurtunity….a very good example is the rss of rajasthan all the rss of rajasthan are sc/st caste people..general people dont get a chance even sc/st people dont have any knowledge they are not capable of being rss but they possess the position of rss this is rediculus …..this rediculos activity should be given a end now its a time to put a end to the caste system the only caste system that should exist is Indian that we all are indian.

  62. Arun Prajapati says:

    Reservation in India is a form of affirmative action designed to improve the well-being of backward and under-represented communities defined primarily by their ‘caste’ (quota-system based on ‘gender’ or ‘religion’). It’s a phenomenon that commenced with the coming into force of the Indian Constitution (the Constitution initially provided reservation to Christians, with the proviso that it would automatically reduce gradually with the efflux of time) – however, lately preferential treatment on regional basis has either been non-statutorily introduced in the educational institutes (e.g. eligibility conditions for candidates from outside the State are 5% higher than that for the ‘locals’, as per local rules prescribed by certain Universities) or is being advocated in both jobs and lowly professions like auto-rickshaw-drivers.

  63. Prateek Agarwal says:

    As for my opinion,reservation should be abolished.i every sector either it was a government or a private sector,a reservation line is very hanged up for a general.we only give a opportunity for a deserving people who face a financial problem or any other single parent child.reservation is a very big issue for GDP also.
    as what i know about reservation,it should be applicable only for a poor people.
    and what about government sector,as it junior or senior,its not a decision part for a public.government should know about who is legal for promotion.

  64. manish jangir says:

    Yes, reservation is paining to every people of India. Reservation do the partion of society and people…
    Reservation make them different to each other. And according to “Indian constitution every people has same freedom and same respect but reservation make it wrong”…
    In the goverment workers it can be see easily, due to reservation they get promotion firstly and after then they get a higher post from his/her seniors… and this thing is very rediculous in goverment jobs…
    OBC is also get reservation but if compair that reservation with SC/ST then that was very few…
    according to me the reservation name complitly remove from indian constitution for same respect and providing jobs to person who is capable for that job……

  65. Lokesh Panwar says:

    Hello. i think that there is no Require for Reservation in Promotions
    Becouse if tha people is realy a good Worker or honest ,.. and do workhard he will surly prmoted becouse every one see his Work or tha upeer class also effecte with his work and will apriseat him….
    If tha cast wise premotion we can see today condition “ALL TAH BANK THERE ARE ST/SC PEOPLE STAY ON THA POST OF MANAGER” i hane see that in tha many bank there is manager are like “ABCD Meena”
    who are belong to Sc cast. So “There will no Reservation in Promotions”

  66. Umang Pareek says:

    According to my views reservation in promotion is not good beacuse we can’t judge any one’s ability on the basis of their cast and category . sc/st having high reservation as compare to other cast like general nd obc. and in our constitution reservation is provide those people that belongs to bellow poverty line . if a people do work in goverment sector then government provides much high salary then the poverty line . and those people not in bellow poverty line . so on behalf of me reservation in promotion is wrong .
    reservation is considerd on behalf of their ability nd poverty .
    thank you

  67. Ajay kumar sharma says:

    it shoud be limit that i known that some students are not good in conditions that read well so that time give reservation is limited after that he get education then in job no having reservation.that time students facing problem which are not having reservation. if he got good percent in exam. but not having reservation then not got job in goverment sector .so reservation is totally remove ya limited

  68. Shashank Khatri says:

    I don’t think that reservation is not to be provided but to whom we provide the reservation is the case,government authorized the reservation to all the sc,s and st,s cast trible but it doesn’t mean that they are backward,reservation is to be provided to whom those who deserve and not be able to do something at its own.The reservation may be provided according to the annual income of the people.

  69. Rohit sharma says:

    reservation not in promotion, because it is divide the caste and now a days the reservation in SC and ST is 15% and 7.5%. we should elemate the reservation only one caste in india that is hindusthani, if we take an example that a persion he is vary good in every field and another person he is not good but he has reservation , in the exam good person deserve 99 out of hunder and poor peeson got 50 he is selected he says many thought that you are so intelegent but u don’t achieve thjat job and etc,,,so if reservation promotion is allow so it allow all caste otherwise it is elemated by government.

  70. Vibhav Somani says:

    Reservation is eating country. Reservation is the main reason behind development. People says that India is one but reservation divide India in several parts. Reservation for SC/ST makes other classes backward. Due to reservation a hard working man does not got as he deserves. Resrvation creates fight in India. Reservation is only for those who are below poverty line. It should not on the basis of cast.

  71. punit arora says:

    As per as my thinking reservation should be abolished completely.it should be probihated specially reservation based on caste systemfrom the very early period we are trying to remove ths caste discrimination. but today on the name of reservation we are supporting it. priority must be given to talent else the day is sure to arrive when there will be reservation to enter into the temples and mosques. people must be promoted on work basis.
    we are “INDIAN” first not belong any caste particularly no matter which religion we have . the prioty should be given to financial poor and talanted person!!!!!

  72. Vaibhav Rawat says:

    if the biggest issue of this modern era is considered while talking with someone apart from the pesonal issues than this is definitely an big issue in the considerations so i think that reservation is one of the biggest problem in india which we had faced from past few years because of its major effects on the entire system..reservation system is totally abandoned from our system and make a single cast which is being a INDIAN..if this change occur in the country then the whole system will free from the cast and rationality by making a single citizen so that every person is equal and no problem will reside due to this an orthodox issue..

  73. Ali Hozefa Bohra says:

    RESERVATION, Wowww!
    when I thinks about this term then feel that like I have not freedom even if my country has and I am sure this situation is with everyone which is loosing its opprtunity because someone nondesrving condidate is getting his position. I also heard from the people of SC and ST that this is very wrong way to give the reservation to a community.
    Well behind anything there is someone responsible. if we talks about the reservatioin starting or objective of resrvation then we know, before freedom there was a lot of castbar between two communities even one person on the chair and the second one is on ground and I want to remember that the person on chair was a genral today and the ground’s person was SC,ST and now they are upon us.
    So basically resrvation was right but it is on wrong way.

  74. Sachin Sharma says:

    reservation in promotion is rediculous..accordind to indian rules there is reservation in promotions..but one thing to be think is that is it right?is’t it spreading inequlity?is’t in killing self respect of a worker who is senior in age,have same knowledge but have a low rank post in same office against the officer who is junior in age? goverment is providing about 15% reservation.this is really a very bad thing for india and should be avoided as soon as possible….in starting a person is facing very much difficulty during selection and after getting selection,he is facing reservation in promotion…his life has become a battlefield..goverment should think over it .

  75. Nitin K Pareta says:

    THEIR SHOULD BE RESERVATION IN INDIA BUT FROM MY SIDE IT SHOULD BE ACCORDING TO ON THE FINANCIAL BASES OF PEOPLE.
    THE OTHER WAY WHICH CAN BE POSSIBLE ,ON THE BASIS OF EXCELLENCE

  76. palash kothari says:

    i think reservation is not necessary today.because it is 21st century and if today we give people the easy way to reach on the high posting and if help them to get a good job easily.then what about the independent generation and what about the competition.reservation is nothing just a way to reach the less educated person at the higher post.and not giving the chance to the hidden talent.and if india want the growth rate higher then reservation will be end now.because today many of the student think that we need to study less and we get the reservation.but general has to survive after they are well educated and complete higher education as compare to the people who get the reservation.so we want our peoples independent not depend on any kind of reservation.they have the capabilty to achieve great success without any reservation.so reservation is not necessary.

  77. Surja Ram Bhagat says:

    Reservation is not the point to take into account when delivering a greater responsibilitity to a man. Promotions should given according to their performance. A man/woman who is serving the people in a better way then other should be eligible for promotion.
    With the people serving feature, the man should fulfill some threshold criteria for that post.
    Experience should also be taken into consideration when we are talking about promotions.
    Reservation was only to make people some upper level but now a days, reservation is the point which is considered by politicians and its a political point.
    According to my point of view reservation should be only for illiterate people to make them literate.

  78. Kamal Kaswan says:

    I think reservation should be no more at this scenerio because it result development of “developed family or categories”.At the time of independence it must be necessary for some parts of indian society as they are socially exploited and economically weak.So if want to follow then we have to discover new grounds like family records for “getting benefit” or “BPL” like policies .

  79. Saurabh Jajoo says:

    reservation was a step taken by the government to give the enough opportunities to the backward people.
    but now it becomes a very major point of distraction. reservation in promotion is the rediculus feet taken by the government. Actually reservation for selection is ok but in promotion the thing to be tested is experience and workability not the cast. by giving reservation you have given a chance to rise them but reservation in promotion means we are making them lazy , and also the good working and experienced person of general cast will not work properly because they knows whatever they do they will not be permoted. so reservation in promotion should be removed.

  80. Arun Kumar says:

    RESERVATION IN PROMOTION NOT GOOD, BECAUSE IN OUR CONSTITUTION RESERVATION IS PROVIDE THAT PEOPLE THAT BELONGS TO BELLOW POVERTY LINE. WHEN ANY PEOPLE DOING SERVICE IN ANY GOVT. SECTOR THEN THE GOVT. PROVIDES SALARY IS MUCH HIGHER THAN THE CRITERIA OF POVERTY LINE. SO THEY NOT BELONGS BELLOW POVERTY LINE. SO THESE PEOPLES NOT DESERVE RESERVATION IN PROMOTION.

  81. Aditya Kushwah says:

    According to me the reservation should be applicable only for those individuals who are lagging with their financial background as they failed to managed even to fill a examination fee. GDP rate of any country depends on the status and capabilities of the citizens, if we are promoting them on the basis of caste & they don’t have such ability to lead them at the peak. Then on what basis they will contribute in the growth of the country, so to be more precise i would like to add by saying that if a guy or girl is making no stone unturned to reach at the peak by doing their work body & soul whereas on the other hand the person who is undeserved for that position reach there without any hardwork & capabilities just because of this caste system. So this is unfair for the deserving candidate as well as for our country. So i would like to conclude that reservation simply creates differences amongst the community.

  82. Swapnil Mishra says:

    i am not here to talk about reservation this is a government stuff because they better know about it. I am here to put my point of view so according to me reservation should not be in government jobs promotions because we can’t judge any one’s ability on the basis of their cast and category .
    If someone who has ability to be promoted then there is no need of reservation because promotion is a part of ability not of cast.If reservation is started on gov. jobs then it is injustice of the people who are not belongs to reserved category but they have potential or ability to be promoted.

  83. Shekh Sadik says:

    See we know that every coin has two faces therefore from my point of views reservation should be there but the aspect is that this should for those people who really need the reservation.Reservation should be irrespective of casteism yes this is for the people who is below poverty line.In some areas muslims are considered as apart from the human society so some consideration should be there for the muslims too.
    so reservation should be there but in a limited percentage so that the other unreserved person not to face problem n not look the reserved person apart from them.
    thank you

  84. Jeetendra Thakur says:

    ITS MY FIRM CONVICTION THAT RESERVATION IS A VERY SENSITIVE TERM FOR BOTH RESERVED AND UNRESERVED CATEGORY SINCE FROM OUR CONSTITUTION HAS MADE………………………………………ON ONE SIDE RESERVED CATEGORY GET SEVERAL OPPURTUNITIES DUE TO THIS.BUT ON THE DARK SIDE UNRESERVED CATEGORY SUFFERS A LOT BECAUSE OF RESERVATION.THERE ALWAYS HAVE BEEN CONFLICTS BETWEEN BOTH UNRERERVED AND RESERVED CATEGORY.SAME THING IS ALSO HAPPENING IN RESERVATION IN PROMOTION.I THINK RESERVATION IN PROMOTION IS NOT A GOOD DEAL.BECAUSE SEVERAL GEN PEOPLE GOT HURT BECAUSE OF THIS PROVINENCE.THIS IS A PAINFUL PROVINENCE TO UNRESERVED PEOPLE.ACTUALLY THE THING IS THAT POLITICIANS FOR MAKING THEIR VOTES FROM S.T/SC IS PLAYING WITH SENTIMENTS OF THE PEOPLE.RESERVATION IN PROMOTION WILL NOT ONLY RAISE THE NEW CONFLICTS IN SOCIETY BUT ALSO HURT THE FEELINGS OF UNRESERVED CATEGORY PEOLE BECAUSE ALL ARE EQUAL WITH THE ASPECTS OF SOCIETY……..AND REGARDING PROMOTION THE PEOPLE WHO REALLY DESERVE TO BE PROMOTED SHOULD BE GET PROMOTED WETHER HE/SHE BELONGS FROM UNRESERVED OR RESERVED CATEGORY……….THIS WILL BE A FAIR DEAL FOR BOTH RESERVED AND RESERVED CATEGORY PEOPLES…………….SO I TOTALLY AGAINST RESERVATION IN PROMOTION BECAUSE PROMOTION SHOULD BE GIVEN ON THE SKILLS BASIS NOT ON THE CAST BASIS…….

  85. Prayas Vyas says:

    According to me, system of our country should be changed because in India everyone has equal rights and i personally believe that by this system general category get suffered.
    By this system, the difference arises between community and due to this some talented candidates are unable to getting a platform for their performance.
    Lots of people missed opportunities due to the reservation. People who are from backward class have a opportunity to do something in favour of their society and improve their financial condition. If a student is weak in studies and scoring an average score in examination then also he get good college.

  86. asish kumar panda says:

    I DONT LIKE RESERVATION PROMOTION BECAUSE ITS PAINFUL FOR US.FOR ITS POLITICIANS ARE MOSTLY BENIFITS.

  87. RAJIB LOCHAN PANIGRAHI says:

    still its going on in favour of SC/ST only , all the politicians are very much concerned about the SC/ST only but why not GEN/OBC .The OBC personnel are not getting any benefits at par with SC/ST .If this will be continued in the future definitely there will be a chance that OBC willbe becoming dalit.

    Reservation is painfull for people.The goverment shoud eliminate the caste system and only one caste remains and that is INDIAN.

  88. Huma fatima says:

    This is completely unacceptable…….this create the differences among the employees…..This will be greatly unfair to those who are to reach their retirements and are serving the country since so long………..

  89. Mamata kumari says:

    Major benefits or reservation goes to entire SC/ST community ,Example is all the Chief Mininster of Jharkahand belongs to SC/ST,none of the GENERAL community had got this position to provide service to their states.I think rerervations shud be their but the rules needs a little bit changes .the reservation shud be given to the weaker section of the society to secure their future.

  90. roshani mishra says:

    If we see one side of it then reservation should be their for those who are really deserving and cannot afford things…but many people who are undeserving getting benefit out of this reservation system..
    If we see the other side then many people who are deserving in general category are left out or dont get benefit because of this reservation system…so the reservation system should be such that neither party gets left out..

  91. Rajeev Ranjan says:

    from the very early period we are trying to remove ths caste discrimination. but today on the name of reservation we are supporting it. priority must be given to talent else the day is sure to arrive when there will be reservation to enter into the temples and mosques. people must be promoted on work basis.

  92. Satyendra Kumar Jha says:

    in my opinion, all the reservation system is wrong in India, reservation with category is totally wrong.

  93. Arpita Sardar says:

    I think reservation is necessary but according to financial condition of a person…not according to their cast..

  94. SHILPA RANJAN says:

    As per as my views are concern reservation should be abolished completely. specially reservation based on caste system.I think we should give priority to those who are deserving candidates although students who are from poor background but they have talent or whose financial condition is bad definitely need reservation..but the students getting reservation on the basis of caste and students getting more marks and thrown out is totally not justified….!!!!!

  95. astha vaish says:

    According to me yes reservation should be there but yes it should be based on seeing the economic conditions of the poor who are suffering a lot for their survival and the poor irrespective of caste or religion should be given opportunities…

    • BHAVYA NARULA says:

      Against: Reservation in Promotions
      Dr. B R Ambedkar added the law of reservation for the backward classes and the Scheduled Tribes at the time of writing the Constitution of India (1950). He gave this law to b under enactment for 20 years from then. He would have thought to give an initial help to such tribes, and 20 years of help to a particular tribe would be sufficient.
      The time period for this law has been extended and so is the percentage of quota.
      The quota that was earlier offered only for higher education seats, is now being demanded in promotion as well. “If any person gets into a good college (through Quota), and possessing required talent, will he still not be able to get a promotion based upon his own capabilities??”
      We all know what is the actual motive of the political parties behind this. Of course it is securing votes from these tribes’ people.
      Comparison An OBC/SC/ST person will have an easy access to a top class college, and then after getting into a government office, he can still use his power to get a promotion. where all these steps of success are required to b taken by putting REAL WORLD EFFORTS by a general category person.

« »