Reservation in Promotions
Last Updated: Mar 11, 2013
Reservation in Promotions
Although reservation in promotion is a matter of group discussion but as India is a free country and I am free to say or speak what so ever i like so i will start to advocate reservation for post of Prime minister , after all most of the time they have been earlier cabinet ministers and then latter in other elections they have been promoted to PM position
Reservation in Promotions
Reservation for SC/ST
Reservation for Minorities
Reservation for Woman
Reservation for refugees
Reservation for physically Handicapped and now Reservation in Promotions
(Bus karo yar Bache ki jan loge kya)
There is proposal to provide reservation to SC and STs in government job promotions at the rate of 15% and 7.5% respectively.This is ridiculous and dangerous step.It will result in conflict in the society and promote inequality ,due to this seniors will became juniors.They are waiting for 30-40 years to get the promotion but due to this there is an injustice between them , the people who are having reservation can get the promotion erlier than the seniors ,this will create an inequality between them. Majority of the benefits that are supposed to go to entire SC/ST community are garned by very few rich and influencial ones. The same gang gets theire priority in everything right from admission to schools ,colleges ,post graduations ,appointments and now ready to in promotions also.
Generally the Indian constitution makers proposed the reservation for 10 years only , but still its going on in favour of SC/ST only , all the politicians are very much concerned about the SC/ST only but why not GEN/OBC .The OBC personnel are not getting any benefits at par with SC/ST .If this will be continued in the future definitely there will be a chance that OBC willbe becoming dalit.
Reservation is painful for people . I would like the reservation be there based on the economic conditions and those who are poor irrespective of caste or religion should be given opportunities . The government should eliminate all caste system and only one caste remains and that is INDIAN.
Please feel free to write your views in the comment section
Tell us Your Queries, Suggestions and Feedback
96 Responses to Reservation in Promotions
« Why we need more entrepreneurs than managers Rat Race to MBA is a Race to Big Money »
GD topics in simple language
Reservation for the SC/ST must be stopped. Reservation takes away the chances of the common people who really deserved that. If we take reservation of seats to be ok but threrafter we cannot take reservation of seats for promotion to be ok.
Promotion should be made according to the capability and qualification and ability not as per the reserved . Reservation may be for certain years but many political party carries on with that in order to increase their vote banks. Reservation against economic condition can be accepted to some extent. Poor peoples due to insufficient money are not able do certain things like courses, purchase job appearing forms . In such cases reservation can be accepted but in all it cant be accepted. Because people should get promotion and other chances in order of their capability not in basis of just reservation.
According to my opinion Reservation should be applicable only for those individual people who are lagging with their financial background and failed to managed for fill a examination fee. Every country have it’s GDP rate and GDP rate of any country depends on the status and capabilities of the citizens. If we are promoting them on the basis of caste (Reservations) & they don’t have such ability to lead them at the peak. So this is unfair for the deserving candidate as well as for our country….
So the entire reservation system need a change and should be done on the economic condition o the people and not on the basis of caste and in promotions it will be done on the basis of the performance of an individual so that he or she will be motivated to perform more better for the growth of the organisation and thus for the country.
so my conclusion is the reservation name complitly remove from indian constitution for same respect and providing jobs to person who is capable for that job……
Reservation is a necessary devil of our country. On one hand, it has played a vital role in uprising of lower casts of India, On the other hand the development of our country as a whole has suffered greatly.In the govt. jobs promotion gets after a very lony time service and perfomance and after that if we judge any one by their cast and not give them promotion in unfair . According to me reservation only for those who are lagging with their financial problem and also good in work and serives .Most of the high post in government sector are occupied by backward class people and giving them promotion on the basis of reservation to them is like icing on cake. Promotions should be made totally on the basis of their performance not on there caste.
According to me the reservation should be applicable only for those individuals who are lagging with their financial background as they failed to managed even to fill a examination fee. GDP rate of any country depends on the status and capabilities of the citizens, if we are promoting them on the basis of caste & they don’t have such ability to lead them at the peak. reservation in promotion not good, because in our constitution reservation is provide that people that belongs to bellow poverty line.Reservation is not the point to take into account when delivering a greater responsibilitity to a man. Promotions should given according to their performance. A man/woman who is serving the people in a better way then other should be eligible for promotion.
First of all writing about the policy.. it’s a real hideous mock of the talented and skillful class of society.
I just don’t understand that if people have the talent to rise to success heights, if the people have the potential to be at the top, if the people have the skills to prove their “metal” in the competitive era then why the hell do we require theses reservation anywhere.. leave alone the case of promotions in jobs ‘n posts?
It’s so simple for the “big heads” sitting above us with “no heads at all” to confide with the fact that even the reserved category students have skills and talents.. far better than the comparative general class.
All they require is “opportunity” and not “reservation.”
Reservation based promotion is going to create sort of job dissatisfaction in the working class of the society. People will oppose.. definitely oppose the idea of any reserved category candidate being promoted before him/her just because he/she belonged to a reserved category, irrespective of the tenure of the work they had been involved in the company, the experience of the individual, the contribution of that person in the company’s turnover, etc.
This is “injustice” in my opinion and never again such filthy policy should be considered for implementation.
reservation was a step taken by the government to give the enough opportunities to the backward people.
but now it becomes a very major point of distraction. reservation in promotion is the rediculus feet taken by the government. Actually reservation for selection is ok but in promotion the thing to be tested is experience and workability not the cast. by giving reservation you have given a chance to rise them but reservation in promotion means we are making them lazy , and also the good working and experienced person of general cast will not work properly because they knows whatever they do they will not be permoted. so reservation in promotion should be removed.
Reservation in promotions is a dangerous step. It will result in conflict in the society and promote inequality. Seniors will became juniors. That’s why SP is opposing the bill, which is also against the basic tenets of the Constitution,” said Mulayam, after meeting a delegation of the Moallim-e-Urdu degree holders.
However, according to press release issued by the SP, Mulayam justified Muslim quota. “Reports of the Sachar committee, the Rangnath Commission found, that the socio-economic status of Muslims is worse than Dalits, hence the minority community needs the benefit of reservation, which will bring them at par with other classes in the society.
Mulayam said that the Congress led UPA government formed the Sachar Committee and Rangnath Commission to study the status of minorities in the country and suggest ways to improve it. However, he added, the major recommendations of the two committees, which included quota in government jobs and educational institutions, have not been implemented. He said that he will continue to mount pressure on the Centre to bring legislation for providing minority quota.
The SP leader also recalled how he along with other leaders struggled for years for implementation of reservation for the other backward classes in government jobs and educational institutions.
Assuring Muslims that ‘one day they will get benefit of reservation’, Mulayam, who recently bailed out the Congress led UPA government at the centre on the issue of foreign direct investment( FDI) in multi-brand retail in the Parliament, said that the Congress and Bhartiya Janta Party(BJP) are working together against formation of a non-Congress-BJP Third Front.
He said that the two parties want Indian politics to revolve around them with no space for a third front. However, Mulayam, who has prime-ministerial ambition, also said that he strongly feels that both the parties will lose in 2014 Lok Sabha elections, paving way for the formation of the Third Front.
Political analysts say that Mulayam is opposing quota in promotion because it affects backward classes and Muslims, apart from upper castes. The SP’s vote bank mainly comprises backward classes and Muslims. However, a small percentage of Dalits have also been supporting the SP.
By opposing reservation in promotions, the Yadav Satrap has taken the risk of losing Dalit votes. However, he seems to be confident about compensating the loss with votes from upper castes, which are impressed by his open opposition to reservation in promotions. At the same time, he wants to keep Muslims in good humour by promising them quota benefit.
IM IN AGAINST OF RESERVATION IN PROMOTION ,
according to me there must be no reservation in promotion,because it must be given according to the ability and knowledge and progress rate of the person who is working in the association.
by giving reservation may be some deserving person wont get the apportunity to excel.
According to me the there should not be any type of reservation for any caste or religion.. Reservation should be totally banned or if it is then it should be totally depends on the economical conditions nor on the basis of caste. If the person has a talent then he/she deserves the seats which are reserved due to reservation and due to this they have to suffer.
There is proposal to provide reservation to SC and STs in government job promotions.This reservation follows the general person throughout his life.
But this reservation system should be eliminated. And give the opportunity to the person who is desirable for the chance.
There are so many problems that are generated by the reservation i.e. corruption. By removing reservation we could get so many solutions for so many problems in india.
I am completely against the Reservation in Promotions.Initially in INDIA Reservation is Proposed for 10 years so that people of backward classes can get a initial help and this time is also sufficient for them to develop themselves BUT today EVEN AFTER 65 YEARS OF INDEPENDENCE Reservation is there and also increasing. Initially Reservation is there in Education, in JOBS but now it is also proposed in PROMOTIONS also.I think it’s not good for a country and the complete Reservation system has to be changed and Reservation should be given on the basis of ECONOMIC condition of a person.In jobs Promotion should be on the basis of quality of a person, his performance so that everyone will be motivated to give their 100% to their work which directly increases the GROWTH of Organisation and also good for country.
i am against the reservation in promotions.in india reservation is based on cast.basically indian constitute allow reservation for 10 years but many politics parties carry this process for their vote banks. if there is reservation then high cast people who is more intelligent then the reserve cast people is miss their opportunity and it is not good for our nation .besides this , less knowledgeable person are in high position and they make decision which slow down our country growth.
AGAINST:
The concept of reservation was initially introduced in Indian constitution to remove the problem of inequality from it’s root which at that time mainly existed as problem for ST/SC’s because of pre independence scenario. It was suggested to be implemented only for initial 20 years but it was keep on extending continues till now, if we really have respect for ideas of constitution makers & believe in our constitution then we should have also respected this idea of theirs.If this Reservation promotion continues in this way no later there would be a time when each caste & tribe of India will demand for it & the main aim of constitution makers to remove INEQUALITY from nation would persist to exist with no final solution.
We do realize that sometimes there do exist a need for providing some extra benefits to some people,but at that time the intellectual act would be decide on questions like what kind of benefits could be provided without doing injustice to others & for how much time it should be given.Like it is right to give educational benefits to economically backward people but this should be done in fields that candidates should be provide with free books but at the same time entrance criteria in any institutions should be truly done on merit basis.There could be many other ways to implement this scheme for which ways should be searched out by government.
I think reservation should based on economic condition of human life. We should give priority to those who are deserving candidates although students who are from poor background but they have talent irrespective
to their cast. But in promotion their should be no reservation because of this junior member becomes senior members along with he have not proper knowledge so this is harmful for social and senior person (deserving person) have to wait so many years for promotions . Thus i think that their should be no reservation in promotion.
I am against the reservation in promotions. In INDIA reservation is based on the caste from more than 60 years which is initially proposed for only 10 years. from starting at very low level that is from school to higher education and then for jobs their is reservation on the basis of caste which is not justified totally now if we also provide the reservation in promotions then they may not justified their work or do their work with the same dedication. So the entire reservation system need a change and should be done on the economic condition o the people and not on the basis of caste and in promotions it will be done on the basis of the performance of an individual so that he or she will be motivated to perform more better for the growth of the organisation and thus for the country.
This increases the differences between castes. And decreases the working power of lower castes.
A general cast man firstly struggle for job and then in job also he has to struggle for promotion.
And we are dipressing the talent by promoting this reservation.
According to me yes reservation should be there but yes it should be based on seeing the economic conditions of the poor who are suffering a lot for their survival and the poor irrespective of caste or religion should be given opportunities…
Obviously, I am against for reservation for promotions , as does everyone. The talent, honesty and hard work towards the job are the only criteria that must be considered while promoting the individual. Promoting a person just because of a surname does not seem to be just enough. It creates a complete chaos moreover block the way to the appropriate candidate.
* the motive for the reservation according to cast was to raise the level of cast and particularly the economical condition of the cast…but this decision of govt. is irrelevant to that is will just create the racism and it will apart the society only.
* some day we will be knowing the India on the base of cast only.
* this is tearing apart the India and not letting the real talent come forward.
* reservation in job giving might be right till a level but then in promotion and increment too….. its pathetic ..